Lemon Cake Pie

I have a confession, I’m a perfectionist.  I hate it when I try something new and it doesn’t turn out.  In the past I  have let this fear hold me back, but I’m doing my best to get over it.  Then the night of the ‘Lemon Cake Pie’ came, and it made me want to give into my perfectionism and only cook or bake things that I KNOW will turn out wonderfully.

This recipe is from Ladies Home Journal – March 2012

I did not make my own crust, used the Pillsbury ready crust instead.

I made this recipe two nights in a row.

The first try was at our Julie & Julia night.  The blasted thing was in the oven for over an hour and REFUSED to set up.  And I tried to think of all the things we may have done wrong.  Should I have used a glass pan instead of my pampered chef pan?  Should we have beaten the egg whites first so that the milk and lemon juice weren’t just sitting there ruining each other?  Should I have tented with foil earlier?  Should we have mixed everything together more?  I just don’t know.  But here is the beauty of our efforts…

lemon cake pie 1

Burnt and gooey? Takes talent to make that happen.

The second night I was on my own and determined to make this thing work.  I beat the egg whites to a frenzy.  I kept the milk and lemon juice separate until everything was ready to be mixed together.  I used a glass pan, just like the picture.  I tented with foil early on, so nothing would be burnt.  I tired to correct any mistakes we may  have made the night before.

lemon cake pie 2

The dent in the middle is where the foil stuck…

It’s a whole lot prettier than the night before – BUT – it still just wouldn’t set up.


After about 45/50 minutes, I cried “Uncle” and pulled it out of the oven to cool.

Lemon Cake Pie

3 c all-purpose flour
1 c shortening

3 tlbsp all-purpose flour
1 c sugar
4 tblsp unsalted butter, melted
Zest of 1 lemon
1/4 c lemon juice – If you’re sqeezing fresh, it takes about 1 1/2 lemons
2 large eggs, yolks and whites separated
1 c milk

To prepare the crust:  In a food processor or with a pastry blender, mix flour and shortening until mixture is the consistency of cornmeal, about 10 pulses.  Add 1/3 to 1/2 cup ice water to form dough.  Divide dough in half.  On a floured surface roll one half into a 12 inch circle and line a 9 inch pie pan; chill in refrigerator.  Freeze remaining dough for later use.

Heat oven to 450 degrees with wire rack in the lower third.  Stir together flour, sugar, butter zest, lemon juice, egg yolks and milk.  In a separate bowl beat egg whites to stiff peaks and fold into lemon mixture.

Pour mixture into crust and bake 10 min.  Reduce oven to 350 degrees and bake until a knife inserted comes out clean, about 30 minutes.  If top of pie gets too dark, tent with foil.

lemon cake pie 3

cartoon-strawberry-9The first night, we all took a spoon to the middle, just to get a taste.  It was TART (lip puckering tart).  The second night, the taste was much milder.  But in the end, the thought of cake and pie having a happy yummy marriage is much sweeter than the actual result.  I’m going to keep trying new things, but this recipe will be put in the ‘Do NOT attempt again’ file.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s